poetry critical

online poetry workshop

it was a winter day. i thought you loved me.

he'd slapped her
[you're a whore]
then smirked.
    just another cliche
    sunny winter day;
    in shade then light - she
    agreed to walk with him
    just after they met
    at the florist around the corner.
    afternoon became - a matinee.
    evening came, passed without fuss.
    night was a cloaked surprise:
  wine and chocolate truffles led
  to them lying naked in bed -
    fine dining his forte, a restaurateur.
    and her's, short dresses, especially red.
    he was also a poet, a 'man
    of words' as he described.
    she was an actress, a temptress, a woman
    without a moment contrived.
  cigarette smoke and a champagne moon
  whirled around, all around, his decadent room.
    in the midst of all those midnight
    upside-down conversations - those
    bare stretches between nothing,
    and everything,
    he wondered aloud -
    'what kind of a woman
       sleeps with a man
         on the day they meet'?
she'd slapped him
[don't judge me]
and left.

15 Feb 07

Rated 8 (8) by 5 users.
Active (5): 5, 8, 8, 8, 9
Inactive (0):

(define the words in this poem)
(36 more poems by this author)

(1 user considers this poem a favorite)

Add A Comment:
Enter the following text to post as unknown: captcha


Ha! I enjoyed that,

Im no expert poet, so my opinion is offered humbly -
Im not a fan of almost opening with the word cliche,
it kind of infects the whole poem with cliche. Perhaps
there's a good reason for that? - I was surprised by the ending...
Also, if it was mine, id probably edit lines 14 and 15 out of the poem,
and perhaps 23,24 (though i do like champagne moon/decadent room),
and condense the words somehow into the three central parts.

Anyway, it made me laugh, thanks!
 — sisotowbel

thanks sisotowbel.

i think i'll keep the cliche. and the cliches.
 — varun

nice poem
 — unknown

 — unknown

wow this is really powerful.  for some reason when i was reading this the song "Tango Roxanne" started playing in my head.
It raises quite the issue in a powerful way.  
I find some of it perhaps a bit too cliche for my taste- her an actress, temptress, etc... maybe not so much cliche but too much "told". I'm very much a fan of the "show don't tell" school, sorry if that sounds annoying.
you are a brilliant writer, thank you.  
 — sarahjoie

I really enjoyed this.  The "cliches" work perfectly!  
The intro and footer are so AMAZING here.  
You have a way of showing how to really use these features, haha.  
I am surprised, however, at the titled portion in italics (is she saying "I thought you loved me"?), either way, I don't quite understand the connection, seeing as they just met.

Nice write varun,
 — jenakajoffer

I don't know. I don't think the cliche worked at all. TH e whole poem kind of bored me. It didn't seem to go anywhere. The ending is 'cute' i guess. I don't know if cute is what you are going for.
 — unknown

thanks jen.

 — unknown

Newest (expand)
Recently Commented (expand)